top of page

Why Google Ads Has a Massive Trust Problem (But You Should Still Use Max Conversions, You Hypocrite)


Cartoon-style digital marketer wearing oversized sunglasses sits confidently at a poker table holding a winning blackjack hand, surrounded by colorful slot machines labeled "Smart Bids" and "Mystery Max" in a vibrant, exaggerated Vegas casino setting. Poker chips and flying coins add to the satirical, high-stakes atmosphere.
When you trust Google Ads’ Max Conversions and somehow hit the jackpot—while PMAX machines in the back keep eating budgets like slot-hungry goblins. 🎰♠️💰 #MarketingGamble #SmartBidsFTW #DigitalAdLuck

Let’s talk about the elephant in the algorithm: Google Ads has a trust problem. And it’s not just a tiny red flag waving in the distance—it’s a full-blown Vegas-style neon sign screaming, “YOU SURE ABOUT THIS?”


Marketers everywhere love to roast Performance Max (PMAX)—and rightfully so. It's like Google shoved a bunch of black box AI nonsense into a blender, hit "liquefy," and then said, “Here! Run your entire advertising budget through this mystery meat smoothie. It'll be fine.”


Spoiler alert: it’s often not fine.


PMAX: Performance Max, Transparency Zero


PMAX is the digital equivalent of giving your wallet to a complete stranger in a trench coat and whispering, “Just get me some conversions, buddy.” No breakdowns, no placements, no control. It’s designed to “simplify” campaigns, which in Big Tech usually means “hide all the things we don’t want you to see.”


And let’s be honest—half the time your ads are showing up on some rando mobile game next to a fart noise soundboard app while you’re wondering why your ROAS looks like a dying echocardiogram.


Agencies complain. Reddit rants. LinkedIn cries for help. And Google? It shrugs and keeps printing money.


But Then... Here Comes Max Conversions


Here’s where it gets deliciously ironic: The same professionals who scream, “Don’t trust Google’s AI!” are turning around and recommending Max Conversions bidding.


Wait... what?


Yes. Max Conversions. As in: “Hey Google, we’re going to let you decide who to show our ads to, how much to bid, and when—because we just trust that your machine overlords will make the right calls.”


It’s basically PMAX Lite with a splash of transparency. You can still choose your campaign types, create real ad groups, and see where your money went. But in the end, you're still putting your faith in the same algorithm that PMAX uses to run wild.


And guess what? It often works—especially when paired with solid conversion tracking and a real offer that doesn't suck.


The Google Ads Paradox: Trust the Machine, But Only Sometimes


We’re stuck in a weird relationship with Google Ads. We don’t trust them, but we need them. It’s like dating someone you know is shady, but they’ve got front-row Beyoncé tickets.


You don't want to use PMAX because it's shady and vague? Cool. But you’re still leaning on Google's AI bidding. You’re not escaping the matrix—you’re just picking a different pill color.

Here’s the deal:


  • PMAX is built for lazy marketers and aggressive algorithms. It removes too much control and gives you zero insight.

  • Max Conversions is AI done (slightly more) right. You still get to steer the ship while letting Google handle the speed and wind direction.


So What’s a Smart Advertiser To Do?


  1. Use Max Conversions… wisely. Make sure you have real conversion tracking set up. If you’re optimizing for button clicks or page views, you're just teaching the AI how to waste your money faster.

  2. Avoid PMAX unless you have a tested funnel, a clear ROAS target, and extra budget to burn. And definitely don’t use it if you’re running local campaigns and don’t have your own tracking stack.

  3. Stop treating Google like a benevolent god. They’re a profit machine. Use their tools—but don’t drink the Kool-AI.

  4. Get aggressive with exclusions, audiences, and creative. Don’t just click “apply recommendation” like a zombie. Take control of what you can.


Final Thought: Google Ads is a Casino (And You’re Not the House)


Trust in digital advertising is like trust in politics—it’s mostly a joke, but you still gotta play the game. PMAX might feel like a scammy slot machine, but Max Conversions? That’s poker. You still need a strategy, and yeah, sometimes the dealer’s shady.


But if you play smart and know when to walk away, you can absolutely beat the house.


Call to Action:


Sick of playing Google’s games blindfolded? Demand Mojo helps small businesses cut through the BS and actually win with digital advertising. Schedule a consultation today:

Comments

bottom of page